5 Steps Small Nonprofits Can Do to Build Donor T.R.U.S.T.

I’ve been following Give.org’s annual Donor Trust Report for years now, and every time it comes out, it reinforces what many of us working in the nonprofit sector already feel in our bones: trust is everything. The 2024 report states, “The ability of the sector to build upon donors’ generosity depends on public trust and on the sector’s alignment with the way people want to be engaged in advancing a greater good.” And yet, there’s still a big gap—67% of people say they need to trust a nonprofit before donating, but only 22% actually do trust nonprofits. The gap is even wider among people who identify as Atheist, Agnostic, or Unaffiliated. For small nonprofits, this can feel like a daunting hurdle. But the good news? You don’t need a huge budget to start building trust—you just need a clear, consistent approach.

Building donor trust isn’t about flashy events or expensive campaigns. For small nonprofits—especially those with tight budgets and tiny teams—it’s about being intentional, transparent, and consistent. And the good news? You can start today, with what you already have.

Here are 5 small practical steps you can do to build and maintain donor T.R.U.S.T.

T – Tell the Truth

This sounds obvious, but it’s worth saying: be honest. Donors don’t expect perfection—they expect integrity. If a program didn’t go as planned, if you’re behind on a goal, or if you had to pivot—tell them. Transparency about challenges builds far more trust than pretending everything’s always going great.

Try this: Send a quarterly “Behind the Scenes” email that shares a real look at what’s working, what’s hard, and how donors are helping.

R – Report Back

Let donors know how their gift made a difference. Too often, organizations wait until the end of the year to send a generic impact report. That’s too long. Don’t make donors guess if their donation mattered—show them.

Try this: After a campaign or event, send a short follow-up with a photo, a quote, or a quick stat. Keep it simple, real, and heartfelt.

U – Understand Your Donors

This doesn’t mean you need expensive donor software. It means listening. Know why your donors give, what they care about, and how they like to be communicated with. Personalized, thoughtful communication goes a long way in making people feel valued.

Try this: Once a month, call a donor and just say thank you. Ask them what inspired their gift. No ask, no agenda—just gratitude and curiosity.

S – Show Up Consistently

Donor trust isn’t built in a single interaction—it’s built over time. You don’t have to post every day or send weekly emails, but you do need to show up consistently. Be where your donors are, and stay connected.

Try this: Pick one communication channel (email, Instagram, etc.) and commit to using it regularly—like sending one update or story each month.

T – Thank Often

Donor appreciation is a trust-building superpower. And it doesn’t have to be fancy—just genuine. A timely thank-you note, a quick email, or even a social media shoutout makes donors feel seen and appreciated.

Try this: Create a “thank you” routine. Maybe every Friday you write a few thank-you notes or send a short video message. Keep it sustainable, but don’t skip it.

Final Thought:

You don’t need a huge team or fancy tools to build donor trust—you just need to be real, responsive, and consistent. Just implement these 5 small steps that your nonprofit can do to build donor T.R.U.S.T. Start small, stay grounded, and remember that trust is a long game. But for small nonprofits? It’s one of the most powerful things you can invest in.

If I can support you in your work let's talk.